Carillion Audit Scandal: KPMG's Role and Consequences Case Study

Carillion Audit Scandal: KPMG's Role and Consequences

If you want to be successful in your assignments and improve your grades, use our case study at Native Assignment Help. Our team of proficient assignment help experts is knowledgeable and experienced enough to produce outstanding papers that meet academic standards. Thus, come together with us at Native Assignment Help for sure success in everything.

Introduction: Carillion Audit Scandal: KPMG's Role and Consequences

The FRC additionally examined the actions of certified public accountants at Carillion with respect to the compilation of monetary statements and other requirements for financial reporting under the accounting program. The KPMG partner who oversaw the audit of defunct outsourcer Carillion has been banned from being an accountant for ten years in July 2022 for giving the government incorrect and deceptive data. The FRC's prosecution section examined whether the certified public accountant had infringed on any pertinent rules related to the professional, ethical, and scientific requirements for audits. When Carillion fell in January 2018, three thousand employees were lost, and the finance and accounting industry came under intense scrutiny amid claims that inspectors had missed significant monetary problems.

Background information

Three further employees on the Carillion audit had their business credentials blocked by the FRC as well. Action that knowingly hinders the FRC's competence to monitor and investigate the efficacy of investigations is particularly dangerous since it compromises the FRC's capacity to defend public interests. The team member who stood before the arbitrator with the least experience, Pratik Paw, was given a harsh scolding but no additional charge. There was nothing to suggest that they had acted dishonestly (Kpmg.com, 2023). Countless journalists have been slain or arrested just for performing what they do in the past year alone. As a consequence of a failing fiscal plan, media organizations have closed their doors. As administrations regulate what can and cannot be published, journalism is increasingly evolving into disinformation throughout much of humanity.

For giving government officials inaccurate and misleading information, the KPMG partner who handled the audit of collapsed outsourcer Carillion was expelled from the accounting classes business for ten years. At the beginning of January, an appeals court heard in-depth information on the imitations, which included records of meetings and worksheets that had been converted into history. Three additional employees on the Carillion audit had their expert credentials barred by the FRC as well.

The most recent episode will start on Monday while an arbitration panel in London examines claims that KPMG, a prior partner at the auditor, and some former and present staff members provided "false and deceitful data or documents" to the regulatory body, the Financial Reporting Council (FRC). KPMG turns down to respond to the queries before the panel. Because of the magnitude of Carillion's catastrophe, auditors and government agencies have been reflecting on it for years.

Audit Quality and potential factors that compromised audit quality

Audit quality has been considered as transparency in financial reports as it provides information regarding the organization's financial condition based on Assets and liabilities where compromise of an audit with the malfunction of financial information conveys misconduct to stakeholders. According to the case study of Carillion liquidation has been ordered by high court in the financial year 2018 for paying creditors. The situation of liquidation of organizational assets valuation has been identified as unjustified due to excessive financial burden collected from the banking organizations (Tiron-Tudor et al. 2021). The organization's profitability and financial condition have not been disclosed with transparency that misleading investors to further invest in this organization. According to the financial report of 2017 Carillion business has been gaining profit of around 845 million whereas dividend has not been paid out to stakeholders which impact equity price a downfall of 70%. The effective leadership by Carillion led to a financial crisis due to an equity price fall of around 70% that provided more trouble for business organizations to sustain ordered books.

Figure 1: Audit point status

Potential factors have been compromised in audit quality like profitability-related information that misleading investors and other stakeholders about company performance. The assets valuation model has been considered to provide information regarding total assets compared to debt where Carillion has not disclosed financial burden has been collected from the banking organization. Comparative financial analysis of the organization based on total assets and debt, Carillion has been identified as an overleveraged company which means Company's financial ability to continue business operations using external debt is higher than total assets. The pension deficit of Carillion has been identified as the largest among FTSE 100 that indicate the organizational ability to manage financial benefits is not effective due to misconduct in profitability volume that leads to the financial deficit (Knechel et al. 2020). The value of Carillion 2 billion to 3,000 suppliers that have been identified as the financial condition of this organization has collapsed due to excessive consumption of raw material compared to production ability. Financial misconduct has been identified in the financial report by evaluation of creditors' value that indicates organizational financial report misconducting different stakeholders and creditors for a continuation of business activity using malfunctioning accounting practice.

Since it offers information about an organization's financial health based on assets and liabilities, audit quality has been viewed as a key component of financial report transparency. When an audit is compromised or financial data is incorrect, stakeholders are informed of wrongdoing. According to the case study of Carillion, the high court ordered the company's liquidation in the 2018 fiscal year in order to pay its creditors (Salijeni et al. 2021). Due to an enormous financial burden, it has been determined that the valuation of organizational assets in a situation of liquidation is unwarranted. The profitability and financial health of the organization have not been transparently acknowledged, deceiving investors into continuing to invest in it.

Figure 2: Audit Performance of KPMG

According to a comparative financial study of the organization's entire asset and debt, Carillion has been classified as an overleveraged company, which indicates it has a greater financial capacity than its whole asset to continue operating. Carillion has the greatest pension deficit among the FTSE 100 companies, which shows that the organization's capacity to manage financial benefits is ineffective owing to misconduct in profitability volume, which results in a financial loss. Potential factors, such as profitability-related information that misleads investors and other stakeholders about firm performance, have undermined audit quality. When comparing entire assets to debt, when Carillion has not disclosed financial burden has been collected from the banking organization, the assets valuation model has been thought to provide information.

Economic and social repercussions of audit failures

Economic freedom has been violated by Carillion using undefined financial reports regarding debts and assets valuation. Economic equity has been considered and organizational performance would be identified for dividend payout to stakeholders that are going to be provided financial transparency and trust among stakeholders and leadership, where Carillion has reported sufficient possibility in the financial year 2017 whereas the dividend has not been paid out to equity holders. After the announcement of the dividend regarding information to stakeholders, equity valuation has fallen by 70%, which created a financial crisis for this organization (Raji et al. 2020). Sufficient dividend payout is a condition of profitability leadership needs to be concerned about economic equity for the long-term sustainability of business operations.

Economic security regarding audit failure has been identified in the financial report of Carillion because correct assets valuation has not been disclosed in the financial report, misleading investors and creditors about the continuation of financial activities. Economic growth is dependent on the performance of organizations where the money laundering act has been implemented in Carillon, which has created instability in the economic situation. An additional impact of economic growth is dependent on organizational performance, which has been distracted by Carillion’s misconduct in financial activities. Excess debt has been consumed by banking organizations, which has created financial deficits in economic growth (Alyaarubi et al., 2021). Economic efficiency is defined as organizational performance and has been conducted with sufficient financial resources that are going to be effective in managing creditors and debts, whereas Carillion has failed to pay creditors' balance and created a financial deficit in the equity market.

The price stability of equity has been monitored by leadership for unethical malfunction of equity valuation, where an unorganized announcement of dividend payout has been impacted as a fall of equity valuation of around 70% that has been considered as instability in pricing. Full employment is dependent on leadership approach and decision-making ability, where the malfunctioning of financial activities becomes a result of insolvency. Employment has been disrupted by Carillion's financial activities, which have been considered an uncertain crisis in employment. Equity valuation decreased by 70% after the dividend announcement in response to information provided to stakeholders, resulting in a financial disaster for this business (Knechel et al., 2022). To ensure the long-term viability of business operations, sufficient dividend payout in the context of profitability is a must. Banks have absorbed excess debt, which has led to a financial shortfall in economic expansion. Economic efficiency is described as an organizational performance that has been carried out with adequate financial resources that are going to be effective in managing creditors and debts, whereas Carillion has been unable to make creditor payments in full and has generated a financial deficit in the stock market.

Current issues and warning signs

Due to exorbitant consumption of raw materials relative to manufacturing capacity, Carillion owes $2 billion to 3000 suppliers, which has been noted as the financial state of this business has crumbled. Financially inappropriate conduct has been found in the financial statement by analyzing the value of the creditors, which shows organizational financial report misbehaviour with multiple stakeholders and creditors for the continuance of the company's operations employing subpar accounting practices (Koval et al. 2019). Various variables, such as profitability-related knowledge that misleads investors as well as additional participants about firm performance, have undermined the standards of auditing. Carillion has the greatest pension imbalance among the FTSE 100 organizations, which shows that the business's ability for overseeing its financial advantages is ineffective owing to misbehaviour in profits volume, which results in an economic loss.

Figure 3: Revenue from 2010 to 2013

When comparing entire assets to debt, when Carillion did not reveal how much cash has been gathered from the banking organization, the assets appraisal model was intended to give evidence. According to a comparative financial study of the company's entire asset and debt, Carillion is currently classified as an overleveraged firm, which suggests it has a higher financial capacity than its whole asset for keeping operating. KPMG itself, a previous business partner, and a few current and previous staff members are the targets of the case. The governmental accusation makes no claims of impropriety related to the conduct of the applicable audits, nor does it allege any claims that the financial records were unlawfully constructed in either circumstance (Alyaarubi et al. 2021). The official charge will be heard by an enforcement panel, which is going to determine if misbehaviour occurred. Separately, the FRC is looking into KPMG's audit of Carillion, the demise of which led to several government-backed studies aimed at raising standards in a sector where KPMG is the dominant player.

The biggest worldwide multidimensional news outlet in the world, a news organization, a branch of Thomson Reuters that specializes in news and the press, reaches over one trillion individuals every day. Individuals may get reliable commercial, financial, national, and worldwide information from Reuters. The KPMG consultant who oversaw the audit of defunct outsourcer Carillion was barred from practicing accounting for ten years for providing government officials with misleading and inaccurate data (Meuwissen and Quick, 2019). As governments control what is permitted to be released, journalism is turning more and more into misinformation for the majority of the population.

Conclusion

Based on the above discussion it can be concluded that, for providing government agencies with misleading and false data, the KPMG partner who handled the audit of the disintegrated outsourcing company Carillion will be barred from entering the field of accounting for ten years starting in July 2022. By examining the worth of the creditors, it was possible to determine financial improper conduct in the balance sheet, which reveals organizational financial report misbehaviour with several stakeholders including creditors for the continuation of the business' operations using poor accounting practices. The KPMG partner who oversaw the audit of defunct outsourcer Carillion was barred from the accounting industry for fifteen years for providing government authorities with misleading and false data.

Nearly 3,000 jobs were lost, and amid suspicions that inspections had overlooked serious fiscal problems, the banking and accounting sectors came under heavy scrutiny. The governmental charge includes no allegations of irregularities in the way the relevant audits were conducted, nor does it make any assertions that the accounting documents were improperly created in either situation. For presenting government authorities with false and erroneous information, the KPMG consultant who conducted the audit of the collapsed outsourcing company Carillion was prohibited from practicing financial reporting for ten years.

References

Alyaarubi, H.J., Alkindi, D.S. and Ahmed, E.R., 2021. Internal Auditing Quality and Earnings Management: Evidence from Sultanate of Oman. Journal of Governance and Integrity, 4(2), pp.115-124.

Alyaarubi, H.J., Alkindi, D.S. and Ahmed, E.R., 2021. Internal Auditing Quality and Earnings Management: Evidence from Sultanate of Oman. Journal of Governance and Integrity, 4(2), pp.115-124.

Bonollo, E., 2019. Measuring supreme audit institutions’ outcomes: current literature and future insights. Public Money & Management, 39(7), pp.468-477.

Knechel, W.R., Thomas, E. and Driskill, M., 2020. Understanding financial auditing from a service perspective. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 81, p.101080.

Knechel, W.R., Thomas, E. and Driskill, M., 2020. Understanding financial auditing from a service perspective. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 81, p.101080.

Koval, V., Nazarova, K., Hordopolov, V., Kopotiienko, T., Miniailo, V. and Diachenko, Y., 2019. Audit in the state economic security system. Management Theory and Studies for Rural Business and Infrastructure Development, 41(3), pp.419-430.

Meuwissen, R. and Quick, R., 2019. The effects of non-audit services on auditor independence: An experimental investigation of supervisory board members’ perceptions. Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, 36, p.100264.

Raji, I.D., Smart, A., White, R.N., Mitchell, M., Gebru, T., Hutchinson, B., Smith-Loud, J., Theron, D. and Barnes, P., 2020, January. Closing the AI accountability gap: Defining an end-to-end framework for internal algorithmic auditing. In Proceedings of the 2020 conference on fairness, accountability, and transparency (pp. 33-44).

Salijeni, G., Samsonova-Taddei, A. and Turley, S., 2021. Understanding how big data technologies reconfigure the nature and organization of financial statement audits: A sociomaterial analysis. European Accounting Review, 30(3), pp.531-555.

Tiron-Tudor, A., Deliu, D., Farcane, N. and Dontu, A., 2021. Managing change with and through blockchain in accountancy organizations: A systematic literature review. Journal of Organizational Change Management.