Contractual Remedies For Construction Law And Dispute Resolution In Respect Of Proposed Burnaby Building Project Case Study

Contractual Remedies For Construction Law And Dispute Resolution In Respect Of Proposed Burnaby Building Project

1. Introduction: Contractual Remedies For Construction Law And Dispute Resolution In Respect Of Proposed Burnaby Building Project

We offer reliable assignment help service UK oriented, with AI-free samples. At Native Assignment Help you have found what you were looking for. To guarantee that every task is done perfectly well, the team of specialists will give you individualized support tailored to your academic requirements.

The report has been commissioned by the University of Portsmouth to examine potential solutions to the following matters of concerns raised by the client. Case analysis is related to the demolishing of one of the Burnaby buildings in the University of Portsmouth and ensuring build newer similar constructions under BS 6187. This case analysis mainly focuses on the legislation that needs to be included in the contract for displacing staff and other equipment to safe locations while carrying out demolishing old Burnaby Buildings. Case analysis will also help us to evaluate legal parameters and appraisal of mechanisms that need to be followed while reinstating IT & power supply electricity facilities before demolishing of old Burnaby building. Perforations on the legislation that can ensure that there is no tampering with existing operations while demolishing the older building of Burnaby also seeks discussion. Case analysis is based on the specific project that has to identify in the project work and these have identified loss of the company and profits sectors of the company products. Companies have written some major risks that are required to solve to get better productivity from the employees to achieve the company goal. Case analysis promotes company products and identifies some related issues to solve for their customers. Some mandatory precautions might be the priority of the University. in this report, those prior concerns have been discussed and analysed thoroughly. These concerns are about the relocation of staff and students before the commencement of demolishing the old building. They should have concerns about the power supply and the IT sector as they played a major role in any university, as per the requirement it has to be in mind that the workflow of the university cannot be hampered in any condition. Therefore there are some important safety measures that are needed to be kept in mind, such as proper hard barricading, fencing, signage, and proper vehicular access point that cannot face any hurdles during the construction work. In this report, it also has been discussed how hazardous materials such as asbestos which is a necessary element in the process but harmful, can be removed. It is an important point to mention that any harmful effect is unacceptable during the work. 

2. Executive summary

This report consists of the various norms and regulations that are maintained by the construction industry. Perforations on the legislation that can ensure that there is no tampering with existing operations while demolishing the older building of Burnaby also seeks discussion. The law only ensures that the construction is done in such a manner that study and other activity not get affected on the university campus. The law only ensures quotations for compensation in case any major changes need to be done at the latter stages during the building demolition process.

Case analysis is based on the specific project that has to identify in the project work and these have identified loss of the company and profits sectors of the company products. The company hire some experienced team members that can help other un experienced teammate to achieve the company's goal. The company has to identify risks and identify the biggest risk of the company that has to shoutout then make a team and provide the best thing to complete and solve companies problems. This problem has to clear their major problems and then look at other problems. Relocation of students and existing staff of the old building is a big challenge for the organisation, the relocation is considered as a temporary relocation for them there are two common ways to impose the relocation process, and they are, enabling their work or inclusion of them in the main work. In this case, there is no way to excuse them for such a long time, so our recommendation is their inclusion in the main workflow because they can be helpful in some ways.

3. Relocation of people

Contract relating to building construction seeks preliminary applications for relocation of people that seems to be done during the demolition and dissimilation process. This law can help ensure that all constructions performed are meeting the criteria and help meet any future clashes with project managers. This should be done when site visits are permitted to the workers during new construction in order to see the view and needs. Policies are set for the length of these visits and a minimum of 2 days are common. During the construction work the existing staff and students of the building cannot be present in the old building because it is a demolishing work and therefore they have needed to be relocated. Relocating a bulk of students and staff is challenging. There are several ways of relocating such as group moves, temporary relocation,  site visiting,  bounces, paid leaves and such.  

In this particular case, temporary relocation is the appropriate one for the existing staff working in the building. In that case, there are two major ways those are, enabling work and Inclusion in the main contract.  

Enabling work means the work for getting the site ready for the main work. This type of work includes Ground clearing, preparation of the site, and several required surveys like ecological survey, environmental survey, geographical and architectural surveys, this type of investigations and assessments regarding the work. It also concentrates on prior work such as hazard testing, measurement of the material, construction erosion and sedimentation control. 

Inclusion in the main contract means that the organisation need to include all the staff working in the old building or all the students that are studying in that building should be included in the separate building that is going to be in working condition. 

in this case, the second option means that inclusion is the better /process to continue the workflow without hampering their mentality could be achieved. Because there is no option for the University of letting them a long leave as that can hamper their fluency in work. 

Relocation of the people has a major part in the case analysis because the case has to understand with the relocation of the people such as employees and customers. the company have to focus on the relocation and identity the problem of the relocation. this problem is required to solve theirs. Relocation can be helpful and can be harmful to the company and its case analysis team. this has to focus on the company benefit that have to be mentioned in the recommendation and solution that have to suggest in the conclusion part of the report or project.

Moreover, for a safe displacement of people, an amendment of NEC4 seems deployable which ensures the company should be held responsible for people's safety at the time of construction demolition and dissimilation process (Markovich, 2020). The project manager will ensure to provide contracts to subcontractors for the relocation of people. First sub-contractors will evacuate all resources from the part of the building which will be used for education in under 2 days (Online.lincoln.ac.uk, 2022).

4. IT/Power Supply

“Article 314.16 b in the NEC” of the NEC4 contract is another major legislation that needs to be followed by me to ensure power and IT is reinstated. I should look after the hooks, which are connected to the power grind in order to ensure the existing grid connectivity. This can be accomplished by making different arrangements with the electric supply provider in order to start the project. The power provider will send a technician to provide temporary poles to supply power, outlets and wires to monitor the bill for use of electricity. When connection to the grid is not feasible then a temporary solar panel is installed which will be providing the required power. Solar power will help to reduce the carbon emissions and lessen the fuel consumption. When I will require lots of reliable and portable power then generators will be purchased to meet the needs. This can help provide electricity overviews in the western parts of the structure when construction is in function in the eastern portion of the construction.

5. Separation of the site from the operational campus

During the time; a construction project is continuing its operations then plan and specifications must ensure the work sites remain isolated from occupied areas. These operations or hazards in the sites will not affect the people of the building. Existing features of the occupied areas must be maintained continuously and alternative exits are to be provided. Existing fire safety systems such as fire alarm, detection and exists are to be maintained properly. Instruction guide is to be obtained during the building permits and specifications by the Education Commissioner. A common complaint is seen as per the facility staff which can be traced for renovation and addition work. The working site must maintain some strict safety measures that can be helpful for the safety of students and staff such as guarding the whole area with hard barricades, and fencing safety as needed. Proper signage can be understood by all the present people. Particular and  safe passages for vehicular access.

6. Asbestos

This clause only ensures provision tender to first subcontractors who will ensure check the asbestos and other hazardous resources in 16 hours' time Workers who are new to the construction industry may not be in touch with the less obvious risks that include harmful exposure to asbestos. This exposure causes “mesothelioma” a rare and aggressive cancer which arises from several decades after ingesting the dusts. Workers working with asbestos often go long to develop this cancer and lung diseases day by day.

The prevention of potentiality in legal actions has taken accurate ranges of resolutions through disputing the problems and diminished the rate of the time management process. As a result, the predominant characteristics have also been improving the wider range of attributes in the construction industrial industries related to "Litigation", "Alternative Disrupt Resolutions (ADR)", and "Arbitration" has created a procedure that has allowed the parties and creations of settlements on the negotiations of the UK.

 The "Dispute Resolutions" have also been effectively considered by making segmentations of the five kinds of attributes related to "Negotiations, Private Judging, Meditations, Arbitations and Cancellations" by omitting the errors-making constructions and "Adjudicatory Dispute Resolutions (ADR)". The improvements and the encouragement through the speedy resolutions have been making a wider range of consumer complaints and ADR has been taking immediate actions of generating the legislation from the 90 days (Financial-ombudsman.org.uk, 2023).

For instance, the proportions of "The Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996" have been also intended for the enhancements of the payment facilities and creation of promptly concerned with the disruptions and supply chain and making a provision of the legislations and providing the ultimate needs among the workers effectively. Therefore, the "Building Act 1984" have been statute that consolidations the previous legislations concerning procedures and makes a specification of the components parts and buildings that have been related to matters in Wales and England (Legislation.gov.uk, 2023).  In this case, the differentiations of aspects related to "Design and Building", "Demolitions of Buildings", and "Equipment, Services and Fittings"have provided the connections with buildings through generations of decision-making approaches.

7. Law relevant to the Burnaby building demolition projects

The principal area of focus by me should be amendments to NEC4 legislations in tenders that ensure the safe displacement of the people and resources for demolition projects of the existing Burnaby site. The Aim of this only report instigates compliance with the NEC Z of building regulations which suggests checking the additional needs for a project (Drobyazkoet al. 2019). This law only ensures that the construction is done in such a manner that study and other activity not get affected on the university campus.This is effective in meeting the first major issue which is people's consent and delay of study that may emerge during the Burnaby building project of Portsmouth University.

The area in construction has been dealing with matters related to "Housing, Construction, Engineering, and Infrastructures" that have been making planning con instructions, engineering and permission by creating a specific understanding based on the two kinds of segmentations related to Contentious and Non-Continuous projects. In addition, the proportion of "The Building and Other Construction Workers Welfare Cess Act, 1996"has been made a mandatory format that has enhanced the rates of safety among the workers with fulfilled the ultimate ranges of determinations (Legislative.gov.in, 2023). The regulations of "Building by-laws" have been making regulations of the architectural and construction aspects of architectural attributes of construction activities that can be making an establishment of the laws and improving the cultural attributes regarding construction projects by making successful projects (Dunlapfiore.com, 2018).

Thus, the development of the construction laws has been creating a greater range of activities by removing their disruptions in a sustainable manner and making a beneficial side by breaching with the party and removing the legislations by generating the changes and making decision-making progress. Throughout the construction, disruptions have also identified the challenges and provided the optimum range of resources by making a successful project and making the availability of the improvements of the successful projects effectively (Dunlapfiore.com, 2018). The construction law resources have also been providing an option to helping with the parties by resolving the issues that can also be resolved the problems by enhancing the rates of creation of successful projects and making familiar legal resources by generations of availability.

However, the legislation related to "Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015" has also been making sensible planning structures by managing the start and coordinating with the working progress by applied with the differentiation of attributes related to "New build, Demolition, Refurbishment, Extensions, Conversions, Repair and Maintenance" by developing the "Construction Industry Advisory Committee (CONIAC)" effectively (Citb.co.uk, 2023). Based on the case scenario it has been specifically interpreted that the construction industry has been also facing multiple ranges of attributes related to "Staff Management, Information Technology supplies, Contract Documentation, and usages of JCT 2016/Q" which have been treated as core issues of this "Contract Management" [Refer to Case Scenario]. 

As a result, the projects have become successful for generations of the new ranges of ideas as well as providing the best services among the customers by the creation of effective ranges of designing modules and making an improvement of creating an effective range of understanding procedures.

8.Evaluation of contract principles and relevant case law relating to construction disputes and assess the management needs

8.1  Assess contract principles and relevant case law related to constructing disputes

For building the demotion of Barnaby I must cling to "Article 314.16 b in the NEC” of the NEC4 (Nittariet al. 2020). This ensures all the connections and power supply are reinstated before cutting any power supply. This contract law is implemented in order to focus on the primary scales that will ensure the detected project interval. This interval will showcase the start and end times in coordination with NEC4 contract norms.  This ensures a better list of attributes which required to be followed to assure studies of the students.

Krishna Kali Mallik vs Babulal Shaw And Ors. (1964) states other major NEC Z of building regulations are other which suggest clearly adhering to the additional requirements while managing the construction projects.

8.2  Management needs resulting from a particular issue with a recommendation

The steps to mitigate the risks in contractual risk are stated below:

Focusing on Avoidance, Reduction, Transference and Acceptance- For avoiding risks, different kinds of steps are available and all of them can be used to mitigate contractual risk. Four major steps are there that can be taken to mitigate contractual risks. The first step that can be taken is Avoidance, the second step that can be taken is Reduction, and the third step that can be taken is Transference. Acceptance is the fourth step that can be taken to reduce contractual risk. Avoidance can be helpful in reducing stress levels regarding g any concept; having a higher level of stress can conduct more mistakes.

Furthermore, it can be helpful to save time too. with Reduction, any individual can understand the type of risks that are supposed to occur and apart from that, it can be also helpful to develop strategies that are going to be helpful in mitigating risks and challenges. Transference comes in handy during the time of passing the liability to a third party that is going to take care of that risks and challenges. The last strategy that can be used is acceptance and with this strategy, the implementation of that strategy, it is easier to monitor the occurring risks and obstacles.

Identify the risk - The first step is to identify the risk area within the current agreement by applications of NEC4 10.1. 

This first project has to reduce its issues and make it easier for the management to overcome identified risks. These risks have to shoot out for their further growth and achievement of the company goal

Embracing new technology -Different kinds of tools and software are available and using them can help to mitigate all kinds of contractual threats. Onspring, TrustCloud, Risk Cloud and AuditBoard are some of the h best risk monitoring tools that can be used for reducing or eliminating all kind of contractual threats that occurs. Using these tools is going to bring different kinds of benefits for handling conceptual risks. These t tools can eliminate all types of threats that are supposed to occur. Furthermore, it can help in decreasing operational losses. Having these tools are going to be helpful in eliminating all type of excessive and unnecessary needs. Combining all of these advantages of risk monitoring tools can help in mitigating contractual risks.

Access and score risks - After the identification of the risk factors, the persons involved in the contract need to evaluate the risks and rate those as per their priority and consequences adhering to NEC4 63.1. These risks have to be clear and managed to overcome for the company's clearance. A company should have to provide an individual concept to become a risk factor.

Collaborating regularly with detailed reviews - Collaborating regularly with detailed reviews bring several types of advantages that are going to be helpful to reduce all kind of contractual risks. During the stages of draft and negotiation, collecting each change that takes place is going to be helpful to identify all kinds of occurring risks. This needs to be mentioned that collaborating on daily reviews is going to be helpful to encourage problem-solving skills. Apart from that, it can be helpful for allowing staff to learn from each other. Learning from each other is going to be to mitigate all kinds of contractual risks that take place. With the implementation of the strategy, employee productivity is going to increase therefore adaptation of this strategy can help to mitigate contractual risks.

Establish a team - With all the information gathered, need to assign work related to risk management strategies among the workers allied with NEC4 X10. This will help to create the company have to establish a team that has the experience and is motivated by the customer's feedback. The company hire some experienced team members that can help other un experienced teammate to achieve the company goal. RACI model (Responsible, Accountable, Consulted and Informed), to involve all the stakeholders including a risk response plan with clear roles and designations as per the risk.

Developing a Rigorous Compliance Framework -This can be one of the best strategies; can for mitigating contractual risks. Following this kind of strategy is going to be helpful in order to decrease the likelihood of penalties and fines. Furthermore, the implementation of this kind of framework is going to be helpful in reducing lawsuits. This needed to mention that compliance firework focuses on automation. Using automation can help in mitigating all types of contractual risks. 

Deal with the biggest risk first - After distributing the work the first thing that needs to be kept in consideration is dealing with the biggest risk that can be harmful to the contract and its benefits and as per the risk priority, the risks need to be mitigated ally with X10 (Januarita&Sumiyati, 2021).The company have hired many teams that are motivated and have some experience it represents their company and helps to become a brand.

Monitor and optimize as per the need - After the risks are mitigated, there will be a need for continuous monitoring and reviewing of the success of the mitigation strategy. This is done to reduce the uncertainty that will affect the planning of risk mitigation ally with the NEC4 Early Warning Register (EWR) (Markovich, 2020). This will help in preparing the management of the risk that will arise if the risk management plan fails in any aspect to prevent losses.

The company have to identify risks and identify the biggest risk of the company that has to shoutout then make a team and provide the best thing to complete and solve companies problems. This problem has to clear their major problems and then look at other problems.

9. Conclusion

This report discusses and mitigates all the issues related to the contract dispute resolution in the Barnaby Demolition Project of Portsmouth University. The risk management strategies are also elaborated and the contract principles are accessed and evaluated in the beginning. This report mitigates these issues which are related to contract dispute relations in the Barnaby Demolition Project of Portsmouth University. The strategies of risk management are described and the principles of contract are accessed with evaluation in the beginning. Special attention is given in order to rectify the measures across the concerned campus and rest assured.

In view of the scenario, it can be concluded that the demolition and construction of the "Burnaby Building" need critical consideration with respect to different issues. The consideration must be emphasized contractual options with respect to equipment relocation, power and staff safety and asbestos removal. Those can help through smooth project management and implementation with mitigation of the occurrence of conflict. It has been observed that the provision of needed to be clear and concisely developed in contrast to different activities.

 Special attention to the area of safety measures across the concerned campus needed to be assured. The contract has to mandate asbestos surveys for the recognition of risks and campus requirements. Therefore, it can be stated that the option between JCT 2016/Q and NEC4 needed to be considered based on the specific needs and requirements of the concerned project. However, the prospects of effective communication, project management and collaboration among the stakeholders of the project are critically essential. 

References

Citb.co.uk (2023). Construction (Design and Management) Regulations. Retrieved from: https://www.citb.co.uk/about-citb/partnerships-and-initiatives/construction-design-and-management-regulations-2015/cdm-regulations/#:~:text=The%20Construction%20(Design%20%26%20Management),%2C%20conversions%2C%20repair%20and%20maintenance/ Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Drobyazko, S., Hryhoruk, I., Pavlova, H., Volchanska, L., &Sergiychuk, S. (2019). Entrepreneurship innovation model for telecommunications enterprises. Journal of Entrepreneurship Education, 22(2), 1-6. Retrieved from:  https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Svetlana-Drobyazko/publication/333161473_ENTREPRENEURSHIP_INNOVATION_MODEL_FOR_TELECOMMUNICATIONS_ENTERPRISES/links/5cde46f392851c4eaba69c53/ENTREPRENEURSHIP-INNOVATION-MODEL-FOR-TELECOMMUNICATIONS-ENTERPRISES.pdf Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Dunlapfiore.com (2018). The importance of construction law resources. Retrieved from: https://www.dunlapfiore.com/blog/2018/06/the-importance-of-construction-law-resources/#:~:text=Though%20construction%20disputes%20can%20be,legal%20resources%20available%20to%20them/ Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Financial-ombudsman.org.uk (2023) Alternative Dispute Resolution. Retrieved from: https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/who-we-are/governance-funding/adr#:~:text=In%202015%20the%20UK%20gave,the%20UK%20and%20the%20EU/ Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Januarita, R., &Sumiyati, Y. (2021). Legal risk management: Can the COVID-19 pandemic be included as a force majeure clause in a contract?. International Journal of Law and Management, 63(2), 219-238. Retrieved from: https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/IJLMA-05-2020-0140/full/html Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Krishna Kali Mallik vs Babulal Shaw And Ors. (1964)

Legislation.gov.uk (2023). Building Act 1984. Retrieved from: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1984/55#:~:text=(a)the%20design%20and%20construction,are%20known%20as%20building%20regulations/ Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Legislative.gov.in (2023). THE BUILDING AND OTHER CONSTRUCTION WORKERS’, WELFARE CESS ACT, 1996, ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS. Retrieved from: https://legislative.gov.in/sites/default/files/A1996-28.pdf/ Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Markovich, R. (2020). Understanding Hohfeld and formalizing legal rights: the Hohfeldian conceptions and their conditional consequences. Studia Logica, 108(1), 129-158. Retrieved from:  https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11225-019-09870-5 Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Marsden, C., Meyer, T., & Brown, I. (2020). Platform values and democratic elections: How can the law regulate digital disinformation?. Computer law & security review, 36, 105373. Retrieved from: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S026736491930384X Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Nittari, G., Khuman, R., Baldoni, S., Pallotta, G., Battineni, G., Sirignano, A., ... & Ricci, G. (2020). Telemedicine practice: review of the current ethical and legal challenges. Telemedicine and e-Health, 26(12), 1427-1437. Retrieved from:   https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/tmj.2019.0158 Retrieved on: 06/02/2023

Online.lincoln.ac.uk (2022) What is the Law of Obligations?. Retrieved from: https://online.lincoln.ac.uk/what-is-the-law-of-obligation/#:~:text=The%20law%20of%20obligation%20refers,be%20enforced%20by%20a%20court/ Retrieved on: 06/02/2023