Multimodal Transport Integration for Enhanced Urban Mobility
Task 1
Introduction
QA is a specified approach that typically moves through the research, designing, building, and supervision stages of a project independently, engaging the design team. The project offers a method for guaranteeing that high-quality spaces are developed and maintained by all necessary stakeholders to the same convenience for all end customers.
Outcomes of the Quality Audit
A process known as quality assurance (QA) is utilized in highway, traffic control, and development schemes to methodically evaluate projects using a series of separate but connected evaluations and ensuring that the gist of location, functionality, upkeep and safety are met. The first step is to define the scheme's vision and goals, which will likely include the following (Malik et al. 2021).
Figure 1: Collision diagram
Establishing the proper equilibrium among both Spot + Mobility having all accessible to all user groups. Given the context, including the presence of more extensive strategic multimodal routes, and the possible impact of a proposal
Ensuring that new locations are of the highest quality while ensuring the quality of the current open spaces is maintained or enhanced with address the needs of the community
Personal safety & road safety
Selecting the correct components and layout in consideration of appearance, hardness, or upkeep requirements
However, the general framework for evaluating such networks is based on various factors that are typically considered in transportation planning.
Figure 2: Stoke Lane
Connectivity
A well-designed network should provide seamless connectivity between different modes of transportation, such as Metro bus, walking, and cycling. This includes providing convenient access to transit stops, pedestrian crossings, and bike paths.
Accessibility
A network should provide equal access to all users, regardless of their physical abilities or socio-economic status. This includes ensuring that transit stops and pedestrian crossings are wheelchair accessible, and that bike path are safe for all cyclists (Fuchs et al. 2019).
Safety
A network should prioritize the safety of all users, including pedestrians, cyclists, and transit riders. This includes providing adequate lighting, well-marked crosswalks, and bike lanes, and minimizing conflicts between different modes of transportation.
A network should be designed to minimize travel time and reduce congestion. This includes optimizing transit schedules, reducing wait times at intersections, and providing efficient connections between different modes of transportation.
Sustainability
A network should be environmentally sustainable, with a focus on reducing greenhouse gas emissions and promoting sustainable transportation options. This includes encouraging cycling and walking, as well as promoting the use of low-emission public transit options like Metro bus.
When evaluating the networks for Metro bus, walking, and cycling routes in the wider area that intersect with Coldharbour/Stoke Lane, these factors should be taken into consideration to ensure that the networks are designed to meet the needs of all users and promote sustainable transportation options (Maulani and Lestari, 2020).
Based on my understanding of typical issues faced by pedestrians in urban areas, the following are some potential problems for walkers and people who use buggies and wheelchairs with the current Coldharbour Lane layout:
Lack of sidewalks
Some sections of Coldharbour Lane may not have dedicated sidewalks for pedestrians to walk on, forcing them to share the road with vehicles.
Narrow sidewalks
Even where sidewalks exist, they may be too narrow to accommodate pedestrians, particularly those with buggies or wheelchairs.
Figure 3: Coldharbour Lane
Uneven or poorly maintained sidewalks
The quality of sidewalks can vary, with some areas having uneven surfaces or being poorly maintained, which can be challenging for people with mobility impairments.
Inadequate crossings
The current layout may not provide enough safe and accessible pedestrian crossings, making it difficult for people to cross the road safely.
Confusing intersections
Some intersections may be confusing for pedestrians to navigate, particularly if there are multiple lanes of traffic or unclear markings.
High traffic volumes and speeds
Coldharbour Lane may have high volumes of traffic and fast-moving vehicles, which can create safety concerns for pedestrians.
Lack of pedestrian amenities
There may be a lack of amenities along the route, such as benches or shelters, which can make the walking experience more comfortable and accessible for all users.
Figure 4: UWE Roundabout
Insufficient lighting
Poor lighting along the route can make it difficult for pedestrians to see and be seen, particularly at night or in low-light conditions. Overall, addressing these potential problems would require careful consideration of the needs and safety of pedestrians and people with mobility impairments. Improvements such as wider sidewalks, more accessible crossings, and better lighting could make Coldharbour Lane a safer and more welcoming place for all users (Tappenden and Skirrow, 2020).
The layout of the significant “UWE East Entrance junction” based on a typical urban intersection, the following are some potential problems that may be present with respect to accommodating movement for all users and the 'place' aspects of the junction:
Conflicting movements
There may be conflicts between different modes of transportation, particularly at peak times, which can create safety concerns for all users. For example, pedestrians and cyclists may be forced to navigate around cars or HGVs, while buses may have difficulty manoeuvring through the junction.
Lack of dedicated cycling infrastructure
The current layout may not include dedicated cycling infrastructure, such as bike lanes or protected intersections, which can make cycling less safe and attractive for users.
Inadequate pedestrian facilities
The junction may not provide adequate pedestrian facilities, such as safe and accessible crossings or adequate lighting, which can create safety concerns for pedestrians.
Inefficient traffic flow
The current layout may not prioritize efficient traffic flow, particularly for public transit users, which can result in delays and increased travel times.
Poor connectivity
The junction may not provide convenient and safe connections for all users to other transportation modes or destinations, which can discourage sustainable transportation options and increase car dependency.
Lack of greenery and amenities
The junction may lack greenery, seating areas, or other amenities, which can detract from the 'place' aspects of the junction and make it a less inviting and attractive destination for users.
Addressing these potential problems would require a comprehensive approach that considers the needs and safety of all users, as well as the 'place' aspects of the junction. Improvements such as dedicated cycling infrastructure, safe and accessible pedestrian crossings, efficient traffic flow, and greenery and amenities can make the junction more attractive and safer for all users, while also creating a more inviting and pleasant 'place' for people to visit and spend time in.
Task 2
The “Coldharbour Lane” link refers to a very important component pertaining to the very wider Metrobus, walking, and cycling network within Bristol, UK. Essentially, it links the “A4174” ring road along with the “University” of the West of England (Law et al. 2020). It refers to the Frenchay campus as well as the Stoke Park “housing” estate in particular. This in turn provides an efficient and safe route for various modes of the transport. The metrobus, walking, and cycling routes are discussed in this section which utilizes the “Coldharbour Lane” link for that matter.
Cycling Route
Coldharbour Lane link comes within the larger cycling network inside Bristol. This link fundamentally connects with various routes of cycling that includes:
Frome Greenway
It is nothing but a span-new route for cycling which connects the “city centre” with the respective northern suburbs inside Bristol and includes the “UWE” Frenchay campus as well. This “Coldharbour Lane” link also renders a very vital link to the “Frome Greenway”. This permits the cyclists to safely travel to and from this “UWE” Frenchay campus for that matter.
The Bath and Bristol Railway Path
The above-mentioned route for cycling is a very popular one which runs along the old railway line right from “Bristol” to Bath. This “Coldharbour Lane” link renders pepper connection to this railway path in general. This in turn enables the cyclist to suitably move to and from “UWE” Frenchay campus as well as the “Stoke Park” housing estate.
Metrobus Route M3
The “Coldharbour Lane” link is the very part of this Metrobus Route “M3” in particular. This link essentially connects Emerson Green with City Centre through the “UWE” Frenchay campus. This route of M3 runs along “A4174” ring road along with turning onto the “Coldharbour Lane” link for the sole purpose of accessing the “UWE” Frenchay campus (Ye et al. 2019). This link suitably renders a very efficient and fast route for the Metrobius users on the whole. This solely reduces the total time of journey and also improves the connectivity between the various sections of the concerned city.
This Coldharbour Lane link fundamentally plays a crucial part within the wider walking, metrobus, and cycling network present inside Bristol. This link significantly connects the several parts which comprise the concerned city. This in turn has turned out to be the provider of a very efficient route as far as the metrobus users, walkers, and cyclists are concerned (Ding et al. 2019). This link also connects with many important routes, such as the Frome Greenway, Bath Railway Path and Bristol respectively. In totality, it improves the degree of connectivity and overall accessibility for all of the users concerned with the aforementioned locations.
Cycle Audit
Cycle audit, which is often referred to as counting, is a method of ensuring inventory correctness by routinely counting a small group of objects rather than conducting a full inventory count. Making ensuring that the levels of inventory in the financial accounts correspond to the real inventory on hand is the aim of cycle audits.
This Coldharbour Lane connection forms a critical part of Bristol's larger walking network. It connects to a number of walking routes that are discussed below:
Both Bristol as well as Bath Rail Trail is a well-liked walking path that connects Bristol and Bath over a historic railway line (Ahmed et al. 2019). Walking enthusiasts can access the Stoke Park residential development and the UWE Frenchay site through the Coldharbour Lane connector, which connects to the railway trail.
Both UWE Frenchay site and Bristol's northern suburbs are connected by a brand-new walking path called the Frome Greenway. From and to the UWE Frenchay campus, walkers can securely and effectively access the Frome Greenway owing to the Coldharbour Lane connector.
Walking Audit
A walking audits is a procedure for assessing the pedestrian movement in a specific region, usually to pinpoint its advantages and disadvantages and offer suggestions for enhancements. The standard steps in a walking audit are listed below in brief:
Planning: Specify the audit's parameters, the subject matter to be examined, and the parties engaged in the process.
Prepare by gathering the relevant information, including maps, images, and statistics on the number of pedestrians and vehicles.
Walking and observing: Take notice of the pedestrian environment while you walk the chosen routes, including the pavements, crossings, lighting, signs, and other features.
Documenting: Take pictures and make notes about your observations, noting any particular problems or worries that have.
One can refer to the guidelines in the Welsh Active Travel Act, in particular sections 10.3 and 10.4, which address network planning, to assess the degree to which Coldharbour / Stoke Lane provides a direct and continuous connection to the larger walking and cycling network.
According to " Wales Active Transport Act Section 10.3 " (Welsh Government, 2022), local authorities must plan and create a network of direct, secure, and practical walking and cycling routes. The Act strongly emphasizes the necessity of creating an ongoing, interconnected network that enables people to move around with ease and efficiency using active forms of transportation.
The necessity of network coherence is covered in “Section 10.4” of the Act, which calls on local authorities to ensure that their walking and cycling networks are simple to comprehend and use (Welsh Government, 2022). Clear and consistent signage, route markers, and maps must be provided to help users navigate the network.
Task 3: Development of a vision statement
A review and evaluation of the strategy document have been given below:
The transportation regulations and guidelines of each location, including their focus on sustainability, active travel, and public transportation.
The layout and construction of the roadways and intersections in each place, including its safety features, usability, and accessibility.
The city's development plans, with a particular emphasis on mixed-use areas, urban renewal, and neighbourhood involvement.
One can determine the best techniques and ideas that could be used to redesign the street and junction at Coldharbour/Stoke Lane based on review and evaluation of the strategy documents of Lancashire County Council, Greater Manchester, Birmingham, and Aylesbury.
Vision Statement
To design a street and junction that meets the needs and goals of the local community while also being safe, sustainable, and inclusive.
Objectives
By structuring the street and junction to avoid conflicts between various types of transportation and lower the likelihood of accidents, you may increase pedestrian and cycling safety.
Figure 5: Cold Harbour /Stoke Lane on the map
Invest in green infrastructure that will benefit the surrounding environment by reducing noise pollution, promoting biodiversity, and improving air quality, such as trees, green walls, and rain gardens.
Encourage active transportation by constructing dedicated pedestrian and bicycle lanes and infrastructure, such as expanded walkways, bike lanes, and safe bike parking.
Help local residents' needs and aspirations by working with neighbourhood businesses and community organizations to determine their top priorities and take into account their comments.
Use materials and technologies that lessen the project's negative environmental impact and lower the cost of long-term maintenance to make sure the redesign is robust and sustainable.
References
Ahmed, S., Meenar, M. and Alam, A., 2019. Designing a Blue-Green Infrastructure (BGI) network: Toward water-sensitive urban growth planning in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Land, 8(9), p.138.
Ding, R., Ujang, N., Hamid, H.B., Manan, M.S.A., Li, R., Albadareen, S.S.M., Nochian, A. and Wu, J., 2019. Application of complex networks theory in urban traffic network researches. Networks and Spatial Economics, 19, pp.1281-1317.
Fuchs, K., Grundmann, T. and Fleisch, E., 2019, October. Towards identification of packaged products via computer vision: Convolutional neural networks for object detection and image classification in retail environments. In Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on the Internet of Things (pp. 1-8).
Gonçalves, J., Santos, B. and Oliveira, A., 2022. Prioritization of railway proximity interventions: The case of the Portuguese railway network. Case studies on transport policy, 10(1), pp.559-571.
Law, S., Seresinhe, C.I., Shen, Y. and Gutierrez-Roig, M., 2020. Street-Frontage-Net: urban image classification using deep convolutional neural networks. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 34(4), pp.681-707.
Mahmood, A., Beltramelli, L., Abedin, S.F., Zeb, S., Mowla, N.I., Hassan, S.A., Sisinni, E. and Gidlund, M., 2021. Industrial IoT in 5G-and-beyond networks: Vision, architecture, and design trends. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, 18(6), pp.4122-4137.
Malik, A., Parks, B., Russell, B., Lin, J.J., Walsh, K., Solomon, K., Zhang, S., Elston, T. and Goodman, S., 2021. Banking on the Belt and Road: Insights from a new global dataset of 13,427 Chinese development projects. Williamsburg, VA: AidData at William & Mary, pp.23-36.
Maulani, Y. and Lestari, S., 2020. Developing Blueprint for Public Services Information System in the District of Indonesia using Enterprise Architecture Planning Method. JOIV: International Journal on Informatics Visualization, 4(4), pp.178-183.
Scoggins, M., Booth, D.B., Fletcher, T., Fork, M., Gonzalez, A., Hale, R.L., Hawley, R.J., Roy, A.H., Bilger, E.E., Bond, N. and Burns, M.J., 2022. Community-powered urban stream restoration: A vision for sustainable and resilient urban ecosystems. Freshwater Science, 41(3), pp.404-419.
Tappenden, K.M. and Skirrow, R.K., 2020. Vision for Geotechnical Asset Management at Alberta Transportation. In Canadian Geotechnical Conference, GeoVirtual.
Welsh Government, 2022, Active Travel Act Guidance, Available at https://www.gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2022-01/active-travel-act-guidance.pdf [Accessed: 17th march 2023]
Winch, G.M. and Msulwa, R., 2019. Building the Northern Powerhouse: The role o f Infrastructure Owners and Operators. Infrastructure@ Manchester, Manchester.
Ye, Y., Richards, D., Lu, Y., Song, X., Zhuang, Y., Zeng, W. and Zhong, T., 2019. Measuring daily accessed street greenery: A human-scale approach for informing better urban planning practices. Landscape and Urban Planning, 191, p.103434.
